名媛直播

Hi emperor,
Could you say to me if sequoia’s seeds need stratification?

Native to california, I would be suppriced if it needs stratification. That is more a demand of trees living in colder climate.

Br
Magnus

Sorry i don’t speak english so fluently. It’s needed or not?

da google translate:

Originario della California, sarei condannato se avesse bisogno di stratificazione. Questa è più una richiesta di alberi che vivono in un clima più freddo.

Br
Magnus

Ok.
Thank you Tropfrog.

Tropfrog wrote: Native to california, I would be suppriced if it needs stratification. That is more a demand of trees living in colder climate.

If you do not know, why even answer?
This leads to confusion:

Luca Frapoli wrote: Sorry i don’t speak english so fluently. It’s needed or not?

Yes they do need cold stratification.
The seeds are protected against germinating too early. You should place the seeds in something moist (soil, tissue with water) for 4 weeks in a cold place.

A nice extensive manual is here: or here

Ahh, for our Nordic trees stratification means keeping the seeds below 0. Now I see that there are freeze stratification and cold stratification. That was new to me. My comment was based out of personal experience of freeze stratification. Thans lb for pointing me in the direction of new knowledge. That is why this forum is so Great, lots of knowledge and experience.

Br
Magnus

Tropfrog wrote: Ahh, for our Nordic trees stratification means keeping the seeds below 0. Now I see that there are freeze stratification and cold stratification. That was new to me. My comment was based out of personal experience of freeze stratification. Thans lb for pointing me in the direction of new knowledge. That is why this forum is so Great, lots of knowledge and experience.

:blink: :whistle: :pinch:

As said before in another thread. No need to explain yourself. And there is soo much you do not know, it is perhaps a good idea to not try and give an answer to each question. You may call it a vendatta against your person. But maybe you could stop and think. If many people who have been growing bonsai for a long time make similar remarks, perhaps it IS about the content you are posting and not about the fact that YOU are posting.

Stratification is just a word for the steps required to break dormancy.

leatherback wrote:

Tropfrog wrote: Ahh, for our Nordic trees stratification means keeping the seeds below 0. Now I see that there are freeze stratification and cold stratification. That was new to me. My comment was based out of personal experience of freeze stratification. Thans lb for pointing me in the direction of new knowledge. That is why this forum is so Great, lots of knowledge and experience.

:blink: :whistle: :pinch:

Is that the alternativ of having the last word?

I think leatherback was very clear and he is right.

About having the last word: you will have it. I know you find the reply button irresistible.