名媛直播

Tropfrog wrote: it was clearly stated that it was based on current knowledge

Which clearly was insufficient, undermining your statement that you have extensive horticulural knowledge.

that dont really applies to my climate

Which proves that you may give wrong advice, not considering other climates.

I clearly stated what my best guess

and made not one, but two mistakes in the process.

Now, please do what you yourself suggested. Let it sink in. Your advice is not very good because of a lack of knowledge and experience. Accept that. Resist the incredible urge you have to yet again respond to defend yourself (I know you will respond, I've already proven you cannot resist it) and let's try and get back on topic.

I'm out.

Thanks for your input Auk.

Yes, I am a beginner, Yes I make misstakes. Not really afraid of doing Them as it is a part of the learning process. No misstakes means no learning.

I have seen you admitted misstakes in other threads as well. Well that is really good and shows potential of learning, of evolving. I dig that and respect that.

This thread is already totally trashed and one more potential beginner scared away. That is by far the biggest misstake done. Lets talk about how we can prevent that in the future instead.

Br
Magnus

Lets talk about how we can prevent that in the future instead.

If you stop replying EVERY question in her, that would be a start. Serious dude, don't you understand you are a danger to peoples tres with all those mistakes?

There are not space for you to learning bonsai by giving wrong advices in here! You should read some books instead, that way you can't kill peoples trees.

Try to answer my post this time, instead of changing the subject.

Thanks for alowing me to post. That is really progress.

First of all, I dont reply to all topics in here. That is a false statement, simply not true.

How can an open discussion forum be combined with restrictions on who can post and what to post? That sounds impossible to me.

If People just stop harrasing each others and creating sterotypes which is not true there will be a lot better discussion climate and people will dare to post more on topic. Sharing each others trees. Isnt that what we all want this forum to be?

I have asked several Times for referenses on where I have given advices that would kill other Peoples trees. Lb did have one that might be thrue depending on the location. Other than that I havent got much constructive feedback on that topic.

I have a few books, I attend my local bonsai club whenever I can and I have spent some 100 hours on internet searhing and learning. And of cource during my short time in the hobby also spent some hours with my trees. Sometimes just staring at Them for hours trying to find out how to get Them to where I want. I am by far not fully educated and have a lot of exciting years ahead.

Was that on topic according to you Hansson? In my mind like 95% of this thread is out of topic, this post as well.

Br
Magnus

I give up....

Hansen wrote: I give up....

So lets agree on getting back to discussions about trees. This conflicts are too tiering for all of us and dont really add anything to the forum.

Br
Magnus

Tropfrog wrote: I have asked several Times for referenses on where I have given advices that would kill other Peoples trees.

Not knowing if a tree is a (sub)tropical or not and still giving advice for its care can kill a tree.
Not recognizing a species and still ggiving advice for its care can kill a tree.
Not knowing there are trees that do NOT loose their leaves in winter and still giving advice for a plant that is dropping its leaves can kill a tree.
Not knowing that certain seeds need stratification will not kill a tree, but it will make the seeds not become a tree.
Do I need to go on ?

Yes Auk. You can go on if you which. But I am not sure if it benefits this thread. Maybe start a new one? What Magnus dont know thread. That would be awsome, lots of knowledge to gain. But please espect me to answer.

Br
Magnus

Tropfrog wrote: Yes Auk. You can go on if you which. But I am not sure if it benefits this thread.

Are you saying your posts benefit this thread? When are you going to actually read what people write and accept that your advise is inadequate, you lack knowledge and experience and that your advice can actually hurt trees?

I have sufficiently proven it. Nothing left to add.