Dunk or drown? It depends.
- Clicio
- Offline Topic Author
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 3555
- Thanks received: 1549
Well, after many pros and cons regarding the dip (not deep) watering technique, some practical facts from experience (please take it with a grain of salt):
- It works to eliminate water pockets right after transplanting (once);
- It works when slip potting and the rootball is compact (once in a while);
- It works when the plant was not barerooted and the substrates are very different in granular size and drainage- in this case is almost impossible to predict when the roots are going to penetrate the new soil; when watered, the water will drain faster through the new substrate and either the old soil will be too wet, or the new soil around it will be too dry; another consequence is the core base of the rootball (the "shin") never getting enough water, specially if the pot is deep.
In this last case, I water normally twice as much the (new) soil around the old soil, and dunk the pot every 15 days or so.
- It DOESN'T WORK as regular watering, and it doesn't save dried up trees.
- It is risky for pines, junipers and conifers in general.
- It works to eliminate water pockets right after transplanting (once);
- It works when slip potting and the rootball is compact (once in a while);
- It works when the plant was not barerooted and the substrates are very different in granular size and drainage- in this case is almost impossible to predict when the roots are going to penetrate the new soil; when watered, the water will drain faster through the new substrate and either the old soil will be too wet, or the new soil around it will be too dry; another consequence is the core base of the rootball (the "shin") never getting enough water, specially if the pot is deep.
In this last case, I water normally twice as much the (new) soil around the old soil, and dunk the pot every 15 days or so.
- It DOESN'T WORK as regular watering, and it doesn't save dried up trees.
- It is risky for pines, junipers and conifers in general.
This image is hidden for guests.
Please log in or register to see it.
Please log in or register to see it.
by Clicio
The following user(s) said Thank You: crent89, leroycoutts
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
- Clicio
- Offline Topic Author
- Platinum Member
- Posts: 3555
- Thanks received: 1549
SORRY!
A mistake: where I say "water pockets", please read "air pockets", here:
"- It works to eliminate water pockets right after transplanting (once);"
A mistake: where I say "water pockets", please read "air pockets", here:
"- It works to eliminate water pockets right after transplanting (once);"
by Clicio
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.